Feeling in the mood to see a show tonight, I asked Derek Noel and Zoe Cooper if they’d wish to join me. Since both said yes, instead of trying our luck on the lottery lines for Dirty Rotten Scoundrels or The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, we chose a show with available student tickets, The Producers.
The Producers was the first Broadway show I’d ever seen (back in 2003 after my prom with Stacey), so I was already aware of what to expect when we walked in to the show. Derek had seen a touring version of the show — and although he didn’t love it, wanted to check out the Broadway version to see if it was any better. Zoe, on the other hand, being from jolly old England, had never seen the show.
Being so far off from the premiere of the show, it was interesting to see how the show was received. I mean, I saw the show in 2003 (2 years after its premiere), but we still had a bunch of people in the crowd (like myself and Stacey) who had never seen the show because of how impossible it was to get tickets when starts Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick were in tow. Back then, ever Springtime For Hitler appearing in the Overture got an ovation. This was not the case on this night. In fact, it seemed as if the energy in the house was somewhat low, until the end of “We Can Do It”, really — but it really started picking up around “Keep it Gay.”
I was kind of interested to see how the leads were. Since Broderick and Lane, the producers of The Producers have been searching for suitable replacements that would lead ticket buyers back in the seats. The cast I had first seen was headed by Don Stephenson and Lewis J. Stadlen, and they were decent, but nothing special. Scratch that, Don Stephenson was allright, but I thought Lewis J. Stadlen was absolutely horrible as Max Bialystock. I was not a fan in the least.
This cast featured Richard Kind as Max Bialystock and Roger Bart as Leo Bloom. I was not impressed with Richard Kind, but he was better than Stadlen by a substantial amount. Roger Bart, on the other hand, was great. I thought he had a pitch-perfect perspective on the character created by Matthew Broderick (well, really by Gene Wilder, but the Broadway version is slightly different), and it was truly believable.
The show-stopper, however, was Brooks Ashmanskas (of Songs for a New World fame) as Carmen Ghia. First off, Carmen is a hilarious part — and Ashmanskas was absolutely fantastic — he completely shattered the walls of my high expectations.
All in all, The Producers is still a great show, over 4 years after its opening. If you’re a student, you can pick up $25 tickets at the box office on weekdays. It’s worth it!


